Skip to main content

Moot claims ADA

By Bashian & Papantoniou
June 04, 2023

Perez v. Due Milla Realty Grp. LLC is a recent court case involving a Title III ADA claim. The defendant in this case was closing operations at the subject premises effective April 9, 2023. The court held that when a public accommodation closes, an ADA claim becomes moot, and a private individual may only obtain injunctive relief for violations of a right granted under Title III; he cannot recover damages.

In this case, the district court dismissed all federal claims for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, and as a result, the district court is precluded from exercising supplemental jurisdiction over the related state-law claims. Therefore, the case was dismissed as moot, and supplemental state law claims were dismissed.

Conclusion: This case highlights the importance of understanding the rules and requirements for pursuing an ADA claim, especially when dealing with a public accommodation that is closing its operations. As this case demonstrates, a plaintiff cannot recover damages in such a situation, and injunctive relief may only be obtained if the plaintiff can establish standing and a real and immediate threat of future injury. Therefore, it is crucial to consult with an experienced attorney who can guide you through the legal process and help you protect your rights as a person with a disability.

  • Related Posts

    09 February 2026
    Why You Should Never Sign an Employment Agreement Without an Attorney’s Review
  • Related Posts

    26 January 2026
    Defending Personal Injury Claims Against Real Property When Uninsured: A New York Property Owner’s Guide
  • Related Posts

    17 December 2025
    Corporate M&A for First-Timers: What to Expect (Without the Jargon)